A Dying Man’s Question; A Turkish Answer

Stan Goldberg, PhD

I was reluctant to tell my new hospice patient in San Francisco that I would be traveling in Turkey for the next two weeks. Two weeks for me was a short amount of time. For a dying man, it would most likely be a significant portion of the life he had left. But it was a trip my wife and I had scheduled six months prior, and as is the case with so many things, my life involves a merging of these two schedules.

“Why do you travel ?” my patient asked.

Judging by the tone of his voice, I thought he was looking for more than the usual common answers such as “to experience another culture,” “to relax,” or any of various reasons related to escaping from an ordinary life.

As I’ve grown older I’ve come to realize that the reasons I traveled when I was younger, has little to do with why I travel now. When I was younger, I traveled to learn about the world. Now, I travel to learn about myself. And in many ways, how I learn when I travel has similarities to how I learn as a hospice volunteer.

Many strange thing happens when you’re at the bedside of a dying man. One is the mystical connection that often develops. If I tried to describe it, you might say, “What on earth does he mean?” So, instead I’ll use a more practical, useful explanation.

I think we all walk around with holes in our souls and minds that cry out to be filled. We may be trying to determine why our relationships are not fulfilling. How we can move on after being offended by an unskillful person. Why we aren’t happy. Or why other distressing conditions remain despite our best efforts to rid ourselves of them.

At the Bedside

What I have continually experienced at the bedside is that the honesty of the person who is dying is so profound, that the lessons they provide me—none of which I ask for—sweep over my consciousness, and where there are holes, the most appropriate ones settle in, and the remainder move on. It’s almost as if I’m on a street in San Francisco with potholes crying out to have a little asphalt thrown into them. The only thing required to fill my holes is to listen and nonjudgmentally observe what I experience.

And that’s what I decided to do in Turkey. Flying over the Atlantic I asked myself what holes I needed to fill. There were many, and instead of choosing one, I decided to do what has always worked in hospice: just observe and allow what was most significant to make on impact on me. I didn’t have long to wait. When we arrived, almost immediately my attention was drawn to aspects of Turkish life that involved “adjustment,” rather than “conflict.”

Observations

I saw it in Muslim women’s head scarves signifying fundamental Islamic values, that were made from the finest European silks. In women wearing gray trench coats hiding everything from neck to ankle, as they walked arm-in-arm with other women who could have stepped out of Vogue.

I heard about it from a tour guide who explained that the ban on wearing head scarves in schools and universities was ignored if they were covered by baseball caps.

I felt it as our driver took us through the ancient streets of Istanbul in an elegant Mercedes touring van with all of the latest electronic devices, as my feet rested on an old Turkish rug that softened the European origin of a car made by a past invader.

I heard it in the form of a digitally recorded call for prayer echoing through the narrow streets in Istanbul from 3000 mosques, as a street musician improvised an accompanying jazz rift on his Kabak Kemane, an ancient bowed instrument, and I watched it on the faces of shop owners intent on completing a business transaction, regardless of the Imam’s words.

I saw it on the walls of the 2200-year-old Hagia Sofia where its conversion from a Byzantine church to a mosque was allowed by Sultan Mehmed II, who refused to destroy the frescoes and mosaics depicting the life of Jesus; instead covering the iconic faces with removable paint and plaster.

I experienced it as diners sat down for an evening meal in an outdoor cafe, and watched a group of eight Muslim woman dressed in black, each with one crutch, some with young children, scream at each other—presumably who had to right to ask for baksheesh (money), as annoyed Muslim non-sectarian policemen ordered them to disperse and stop bothering the tourists.

In horror, I witnessed  the inability to adjust as a cruise ship passenger—one of thousands—cuing in line to see the Sultan’s treasures, yelled at people behind him who were six abreast “Not to jump the line,” while ignoring the exquisite carvings in front of him.

I heard it in the sound of the metro trolley hooting it’s horn as an Asian tourist stood in front of it snapping endless photographs while expecting the car to slow down in order for him to take home the perfect shot—and it did.

I saw it watching poor children diving between multi-million-dollar mansions on the Bosphorus with its treacherous tides, trying to cool off during the unseasonably hot September afternoon while old men wearing tattered clothes caught anchovies on multiple hooks for their families evening meal.

I heard it listening to people extolling the quality of Armenian and Kurdish food as if neither culture had a painful history in Turkey.

In Cappadocia I felt it crawling through endless caves dug into the soft rocks by Christians in the first century, preferring life without sunlight to death by Roman soldiers.

I witnessed it in the farmlands surrounding Izmir as Muslim men and women avoided eye contact on the road as my wife reminded me that saying hello to everyone, especially women was not a culturally correct thing to do.

I felt it rising at dawn in a hot air balloon over Göreme and saw the wonders of this country on a vessel guided by wind, something the pilot had no control over.

I tasted it when offered pumpkin seeds in a field whose meat was always left for the animals to eat.

I marveled at the cats who respectfully sat on the pavement by my table and waited for me to offer them food, gracefully moving on when I didn’t.

I felt it in the coldness of the onyx blades used to carve out an underground city that housed 40,000 people, that 1000 years later would be used to make lifeless miniature Sufis for the tourist trade.

And I imagined the thousands of pidgins at the entrance of 3000-year-old caves signaling the approach of Roman Legends, while providing it’s inhabitants with eggs, meat, and guano.

Answering a Dying Man’s Question

So what did I learn from this 8000-mile journey that crossed 11 time zones? We have choices in life: we can either adjust to the circumstances over which we may have little or no control, or pretend that we do, and as did the few early Christians who didn’t want to live in caves, endure consequences far worse than not seeing the sun.

Possibly I could have learned the same lesson closer to home, say in Daly City or Hayward. But then, it wouldn’t have been an adventure and I wouldn’t have realized the importance of visiting cities where cruise ships don’t dock.

Preventing Senior Moments, by Stan Goldberg

Offers practical and achievable prevention strategies for senior moments.

Coming October 2023!

26 Comments

  1. Natalie

    So simple and yet you have expertely described Turkey perfectly. I love in one of the touristic resorts and many visitors do not see the life and culture behind the scences. They often get a shock when they do!

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Thanks for your kind words Natalie. Turkey was a delight (no pun intended). Such a great mix of cultures. Both my wife and I would love to go back.

      Reply
  2. Mary Hamilton

    It’s kind of like unconditional love . . . it just is! No premonitions, no expectations, no disappointments. It just is . . . unconditional love. Right, Stan?

    Reply
  3. David

    Stan, this is a marvelous page..and although I am not a hospice worker, some of the things you describe really resonate with me. I do think that by letting go of trying to have control over what needs to be fixed, or holes to be filled in life, that if you are simply open and accepting, those things can often times resolve on their own…or lose their significance altogether…

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Hi David,
      As my mother would say when we discussed things that “should” occur, “From your lips to his ears.” I agree completely that often letting go and accepting what is, is more rewarding than trying to hold onto something with the permanency of a pile of sand. As someone who interacts with dying patients and their families, facilitating that understanding is something that I often struggle with.

      Reply
      • David

        Stan, you’re giving me even more to think about – 🙂 Thanks for your reply – I have never heard the ‘permanency of a pile of sand’ analogy – which is wonderful. Thank you – again, your writing, even in your comment replies, is terrific…have a terrific weekend.

  4. Damiano de Sano Iocovozzi

    Dear Stan, What a lovely article of your trip to Turkey! I really was moved by my experiences in Turkey and now yours’. Thanks for the memories & how you see travel now. Sincerely, Damiano

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Hi Damiano,

      Thanks for your kind words. The 11 hour time difference was a killer. I think I’ll stick to 2 or 3 time zone differences for future travel.

      Stan

      Reply
  5. Jan Bergmans

    Hi Stan

    Thanks for another nice piece of writing.
    I was momentarily there 😉

    Jan

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      You’re very welcome, as always Jan. Maybe next visit till be close to you in Europe.

      Stan

      Reply
  6. Paula Camposano Robinson

    Dear Stan,
    As always, a very meaningful journey through life. You are a such a blessing to your hospice patients and to all of us who learn something from every post you write! Thank you for being the humble yet remarkable man that you are. It is an honor to know you!

    Always,
    Paula

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Thanks for your kind words Paula. The publication day for my book on caregiving has been set for March, 2012.

      Reply
  7. Sharon Bach

    Stan,

    You have articulated perfectly why it is that I travel, and have taken me back to Turkey. It is always in the myriad little nuances of a day in another unfamiliar place that alights all our senses and reminds us to be fully alive. Thank you very much for putting pen to paper (fingers to keyboard?) and writing this for all of us!

    Sharon

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      You’re very welcome Sharon. I was too tired on the hike to adequately describe my experiences in Turkey.

      Take Care,
      Stan

      Reply
  8. Katharine Dupre

    Isn’t it amazing what we can learn if we simply keep ourselves open to life? Thanks for writing the article. I can see big changes in your perspective since the writing class.

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Thanks Katharine,
      It’s been a long and torturous road. But then, nobody said learning would be easy.

      Take Care,
      Stan

      Reply
  9. Steve Evans

    Stan,
    First, a mind trip as illuminating as ever! For some reason, just for myself, I felt more comfotable substituting the word accommodation in lieu of adjustment. “Adjusting” permits both changing the thing — and/or changes in ourselves in response — while accommodation emphasizes changes in ourselves in response. I think you emphasized the latter quite well … but the individual stylist in me [ego] arises now and then. However I am delighted to accommodate your word choice :)))

    Hospice care, I would believe, includes the sacred art of truly listening. In that sense, the Universe is always speaking and we may similarly choose to listen — or not. Perhaps travel sometimes can simply be an opportuniity to allow our inner selves to listen with an ear that might have become more tone deaf in our regular settings.

    Thank you again my friend for the chance to “listen up.”

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Hi Steve,
      Interestingly, I struggled with choosing between “adjusting” and “accommodating.” In my mind, accommodating involved more of an acceptance of differing values than adjusting does. I may be just a semantic difference, but what I experienced was allowing differences to exist without accepting them. And, I hope I’m wrong, but in that analysis I can see problems ahead for Turkey. Well, I guess it’s just my old political science proclivities coming through. Best to Betty. I would be interested in what she thinks about Turkey.

      Take Care,
      Stan

      Reply
  10. David Michie

    Wonderful observations and insights, as always, Stan. I sometimes think that it’s only by travelling, and experiencing a basis for comparison, that we learn about our own society and culture. A man who has always lived on Planet Green may not realise it is green until he visits Planet Yellow.

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Hi David,
      Thanks for your kind words. I agree completely with your thoughts. But I wish I can make the same observations I did in Turkey closer to home–say 2 or 3 time zones away rather than 11!

      Take care,
      Stan

      Reply
  11. Ronee

    Stan, you have such a gift of presenting the reader with the emotions of the moment! I felt I was there with you, observing as you did…
    Thank you! So much!
    Ronee

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Thanks for your kind words Ronee. The subject matter almost wrote the words by itself.

      Take Care,
      Stan

      Reply
  12. Barry Willdorf

    Sounds like you had a very introspective trip and came away with lessons and memories not to be forgotten. I guess you got your money’s worth Best to Wendy. See you soon.
    Barry

    Reply
    • Stan Goldberg

      Hi Barry,

      I was pleasingly surprised. I’ll email you.

      Stan

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Ronee Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts